Quote:first if ya read my post ya should have read why i don't want a mod to be reviewed and re-reviewed again, cos it's the point of not gettin approvement to hard and long awaitin.
Now, if you'd actually SAID that last bit in your post, maybe I might've had the opportunity to read it...
Quote:and i do think i does make sense that the first reviewer gives feedback to modauthors quickly and if there are big bugs there is no need for the other two reviewers to test the same bugs
Well, you've got a point about testing the same bugs over, but the whole idea of more than one tester is the repetitiveness! You're missing the point: we're trying to make it so that one unfair, biased person can't just go and reject someone's mod. Having two or three people review the mod makes sure that a mod doesn't get rejected (or accepted) without reason. As XXL said:
Quote:The main reason for let more than one person test the mod is to prevent unfair ratings! In addition, two testers might find more bugs than one.
Quote:but if the code was corrected the first reviewer is okay with it, then there is sence in the second and third testers work after that
And if the first tester made a mistake and/or is stupid and a bad mod gets accepted? No thanks, I think I'd like double or triple assurance.
Quote:there should be nothing hard to code for this point, just add a field where the first reviewer can set the status to "in work", so other testers see someone is already testing it
Two or three people should be able to review the mod at the same time, to make the process as quick as possible. There's no reason to wait until one person is done to let the other person have a crack at it.
Quote:Well there is no reason to wait with mod reviewing. However I suggest not to put the testers under pressure.
Exactly, that's why I planned on having a queue. A mod would get assigned to a tester for review only whenever the tester logged in to get a mod for review. Otherwise, if mods were assigned automatically, testers would feel pressured, reviewers would become inactive and leave mods hanging, and things would be a total mess.
Quote:You have to consider that we all have a real life too.
No!
Ahhhhh!